It’s 8am, there’s a warm bagel in one hand and a coffee in the other, and the subway doors open a block from the museum you came for. That feeling of already being where the day happens is what you’re really choosing when you decide where to stay in New York. Pick well and the city works for you. Pick badly and you spend half your trip underground.
For most first-timers it comes down to two boroughs: Manhattan, where the postcards live, or Brooklyn, where a lot of New Yorkers actually do. Both work. They just give you very different trips.
Below you’ll find the best neighborhoods on each side of the East River, what they really cost, how long the subway takes, and the rental rule that catches plenty of visitors out. Once you’ve picked a base, keep our full list of New York City tours and guides open for planning the fun part.
At a glance
- Best for a first 3 to 5 days: Manhattan (Midtown, Chelsea, the Village)
- Best for value and local feel: Brooklyn (Williamsburg, DUMBO, Downtown Brooklyn)
- Subway from Brooklyn to Midtown: roughly 20 to 45 minutes, depending on the neighborhood
- Budget: Brooklyn rooms are often cheaper, but always compare the total with taxes and fees
- Getting around: tap a contactless card or phone at the subway gate; trains run 24 hours
Manhattan vs Brooklyn: the quick verdict
If this is your first trip and you have less than a week, stay in Manhattan. Central Park, the Empire State Building, the big museums and Broadway all sit within a short subway ride or a long, happy walk of each other. You’ll lose less time, and you can pop back to the hotel between the morning’s museum and the evening’s show.
Brooklyn makes sense when you have five days or more, care more about food and neighborhoods than ticking off landmarks, or want more room for your money. It’s not a compromise. Some of the best skyline views in the city are from the Brooklyn side, looking back.
The honest middle ground? A Brooklyn neighborhood one or two subway stops from Manhattan. You get calmer streets and still reach Lower Manhattan in minutes. That’s the smartest answer to where to stay in New York if you can’t decide.
Best Manhattan neighborhoods for first-timers
Midtown: close to everything, quiet to nothing
Midtown puts you near Times Square, Rockefeller Center, Bryant Park, Grand Central and the Broadway theaters. Nearly every subway line runs through it, so reaching anywhere is easy. The trade-off is sirens at 2am, crowds at every crossing and a lot of chain restaurants. Look a few blocks east or west of Times Square rather than right on it. You’ll sleep better and still walk to your show.
Chelsea, Flatiron and Union Square: the sweet spot
This stretch feels like a real neighborhood but keeps you central. Walk the High Line while it’s still cool, graze your way through Chelsea Market, then wander the farmers market stalls at Union Square on market days, when the air smells like apples and fresh bread. The subway connections at Union Square are some of the best in the city.
Greenwich Village and the Lower East Side: for long evenings
Leafy streets, tiny restaurants, jazz drifting up from basement clubs and street performers in Washington Square Park. The Lower East Side next door is louder and later, with bars that only get going after 10pm. Perfect if your trip revolves around dinner and drinks. Less perfect if you’re asleep by 10.
Upper West Side: calm, green and good for families
You’re steps from Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History, surrounded by delis, bakeries and brownstone blocks that feel almost residential. It’s quiet at night, which families love and night owls don’t. The 1, 2 and 3 trains get you downtown fast.
Best Brooklyn neighborhoods (and how far they really are)
Williamsburg: food, bars and one stop to Manhattan
Williamsburg is the Brooklyn most people picture: rooftop bars, vintage shops along Bedford Avenue and waterfront parks with the whole Manhattan skyline across the river. On warm weekends, outdoor food markets turn the waterfront into one long tasting menu. The L train crosses into Manhattan in a single stop, so you can be in the East Village before your coffee cools.
DUMBO and Brooklyn Heights: the views
Cobblestones, old brick warehouses and that famous shot of the Manhattan Bridge framed between buildings on Washington Street. Next door, Brooklyn Heights has quiet brownstone blocks and the Promenade, a walkway with a wide-open view of Lower Manhattan that glows at sunset. From Clark Street, the 2 and 3 trains reach Wall Street in one stop. Hotels are fewer here and rarely cheap, but you’re paying for the view you wake up to.
Downtown Brooklyn: the practical pick
Downtown Brooklyn has most of the borough’s hotels and a tangle of subway lines, which makes it the easiest Brooklyn base for first-timers. It’s more office towers than charm. Still, DUMBO, Brooklyn Heights and the Barclays Center are all walkable, and Midtown is often around half an hour away.
Park Slope: for families and slower trips
Brownstone streets, stroller-friendly cafés and Prospect Park at the end of the block. It’s lovely for a longer stay, but it’s the farthest of these four from Midtown, so plan on closer to 40 minutes each way. The city’s official tourism site has a good overview of Brooklyn’s neighborhoods if you want to dig further.

What a New York hotel really costs (and the Airbnb catch)
New York hotels are expensive, full stop. As a rough rule, Brooklyn rooms often cost less than similar ones in Manhattan, and they tend to be a little bigger. The gap isn’t guaranteed, though. A waterfront hotel in Williamsburg can cost more than a basic room in Midtown.
Always compare the final price. Hotel taxes add a noticeable chunk on top of the nightly rate, and some hotels charge extra fees for things like Wi-Fi or the gym. Rates swing with the seasons too, peaking around the winter holidays and in the fall, and dropping in the cold weeks after New Year. Check the hotel’s own site for current prices before you commit.
That rule is why hotels, not apartments, are the realistic choice for most short visits, in both boroughs.
Getting around from Manhattan or Brooklyn
Wherever you stay, the subway is your best friend. It runs 24 hours, and you pay by tapping a contactless card or phone at the gate: one flat fare per ride, no matter how far you go. Before you pick a hotel, check which lines stop nearby. A station with several lines beats a closer station with one.
Late at night, trains run less often and some lines change routes, so if you’re sleeping in Brooklyn and planning big nights in Manhattan, budget extra time or a taxi home. Rush hour, roughly 8 to 9am and 5 to 7pm, packs the trains heading into Midtown shoulder to shoulder.
Landing early or flying out late? Most hotels hold bags, but if yours won’t, you can leave your luggage at a storage spot near the station and start exploring instead of waiting for check-in.
Where to stay in New York for your kind of trip
- First visit, 3 to 4 days: Midtown or Chelsea, so every big sight is close.
- Foodies and night owls: the East Village, the Lower East Side or Williamsburg.
- Families: the Upper West Side for Central Park and the museums, or Park Slope for a slower pace.
- Couples: Greenwich Village or Brooklyn Heights, for pretty streets and after-dinner walks.
- Tighter budget: Downtown Brooklyn, or the Financial District on weekends.
- Second visit: Brooklyn, no question. You’ve seen Times Square. Now see where people live.
Once you’ve narrowed it down, search the exact neighborhood name rather than just “New York” so you only see hotels in the area you actually want.
Skip this, do that
Skip a hotel right on Times Square because it looks central on the map. It’s loud around the clock, and every morning starts with a shove through the crowds.
Do stay ten minutes’ walk away, near Bryant Park or in Hell’s Kitchen, where dinner is better and usually cheaper.
Skip a bargain Brooklyn hotel far out on a single subway line. Do pay a little more to be one or two stops from Manhattan. Your time is the priciest thing on this trip.
Questions travelers ask
Is it better to stay in Manhattan or Brooklyn on a first trip?
For a short first trip, Manhattan usually wins because the major sights are close together and you’ll spend less time commuting. Brooklyn is a great choice for longer stays, repeat visits or travelers who prefer food and neighborhood life over landmarks.
Is Brooklyn safe for tourists?
The Brooklyn neighborhoods in this guide are popular, busy areas full of locals and visitors day and night. Use the same street sense you would in any big city: watch your phone on crowded trains and pick well-lit routes back to your hotel late at night.
How long does it take to get from Brooklyn to Times Square?
From Williamsburg, DUMBO or Downtown Brooklyn, it’s often 20 to 35 minutes by subway. From Park Slope or neighborhoods farther out, expect closer to 40 minutes or more, especially late at night when trains run less often.
Can I rent an Airbnb in New York City?
Only in limited cases. For stays under 30 nights, the city generally requires the host to be registered, live in the home and stay there during your visit, with no more than two guests. That’s why most visitors deciding where to stay in New York end up in a hotel.
One last trick before you go: whichever borough you choose, spend at least one evening on the other side. Staying in Manhattan? Head to the Brooklyn waterfront for sunset and watch the towers light up across the water. Staying in Brooklyn? Take a late stroll through the Village and ride the train home with the city still buzzing. And if you’re stringing together a bigger trip, browse more guides from across the United States, or see how the same pick-your-base thinking works in our Tokyo neighborhood guide for first-timers.
Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you book through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Cover photo by Ramon Perucho on Pexels